From B. J. Griswold, THE PICTORIAL HISTORY OF FORT WAYNE, INDIANA and THE STORY OF THE TOWNSHIPS OF ALLEN COUNTY, by Mrs. Samuel R. Taylor, Chicago, Robert O. Law Company, 1917
DAVID M. SHOAFF, who came to Allen County in 1839, with his brave young wife, MARY MENDENHALL, and their 2 little babes, had their share of hardships, and triumphs also. Young, moneyless, and with very little else than pluck, they made their way, MR. SHOAFF working in the winters for better situated neighbors at the princely stipend of 50 cents a day, and spending the summer at his own clearing, in which work MARY helped him, gathering and burning brush while her babies played at a safe distance on the ground. Safe distance, do we say? As if any distance were safe in a country which harbored wild animals and teemed with snakes not all of which were harmless. Who can tell what fears assailed the young pioneer mother’s heart at the slightest call of distress from her little ones while she worked to help make them a home? Among other incidents attending the pioneer life of DAVID SHOAFF is related a memorable trip he made to Maumee City, Ohio. Salt it seems was selling in Fort Wayne for $9 per barrel in the spring of 1840. This was deemed too high a price to pay with wages at 50 cents per day. Still, salt was a necessity. A brother, JAMES P. SHOAFF, furnished the money and DAVID SHOAFF and F. C. FREEMAN undertook the trip. It was early March and the snow was so deep and heavy that it took 12 days to reach Maumee City. The return trip was made by way of the still frozen Maumee River, a route quite common in winter, but fraught with some danger in March. They had some narrow escapes from drowning, though they reached home safely at last, but it was a rather expensive barrel of salt after all, even reckoning their wages at 50 cents a day. The arrow that flieth by day had been driven from the woods, but arrows were not all the risks that beset the settler’s path to fortune. When in the fall of 1843 DAVID SHOAFF helped to build the houses of his brother J. P. SHOAFF, and SQUIRE JONES, they were the first houses between his own home and Heller’s Corners on that road which ADAM HULL and his neighbors helped to cut. DAVID SHOAFF and RAPIN ANDREWS, though coming to Perry at nearly the same time, but in quite different circumstances, were both there in time to be two of the 11 voters in the township to cast a vote at the first presidential election held there. DAVID was a Whig.
_______________________________________________________________
SHOAFF CENSUS
1850 Census of Perry Township, Allen Co., IN #2645-2657
David Shoaff 36 M Farmer born Ohio
Mary Shoaff 31 F born Ohio
Peter Shoaff 14 M born Ohio
Samuel Shoaff 10 M born Ohio
Almina Shoaff 8 F born Ohio
John Shoaff 6 M born IN
Cornelie Shoaff 3 F born IN
Frances Hemphill 34 F born NC
1880 Census of Perry Township, Allen Co., IN 194 A
David M. Shoaff married male, 65 born Ohio Farmer
Both parents born PA
Mary Shoaff wife female, 60 born Ohio Keeps house
Both parents born NC
John P. J. Shoaff son, widower male, 34 born IN Harness Maker
Almira Allen gr. dau female, 16 born IN At home
Both parents born Ohio
David W. Shoaff gr. son male, 13 born IN At home
Father born Ohio, Mother born IN
William Burl son-in-law male, 32 born Ohio Farmer
Both parents born Ohio
Emma Burl daughter female, 32 born IN Keeps house
Both parents born Ohio
1880 Census of Eel River Township, Allen Co., IN 180 A
John P. Shoaff widower male, 75 born MD Farmer
Both parents born PA
W. S. Shoaff son, single male, 32 born IN At home
Father born MD, Mother born Ohio
Sarah Davis other, single female, 19 born Eng. Servant
William Harrison other male, 15 born IN Works on farm
(J. P. Shoaff was married to Priscilla Freeman)
1880 Census of Eel River Township, Allen Co., IN 180 A
James B. Shoaff married male, 39 born IN Farmer
Father born MD, Mother born Ohio
Hulda Shoaff wife female, 34 born Ohio Keeps house
Both parents born Ohio
Oran L. Shoaff son male, 14 born IN
Terry Shoaff son male, 12 born IN
Jenney Shoaff daughter female, 11 born IN
Freddie Shoaff son male, 3 born IN
R. Crumley other, single male, 20 born IN Works on farm
Both parents born IN
Probable son, Peter, of David M. Shoaff??
1880 Census of Butler Township, DeKalb County, IN 193 B
Peter Shoaff married male, 43 born Ohio Farmer
Both parents born Ohio
Mary F. Shoaff wife female, 39 born IN Keeps house
Father born Ohio, Mother born IN
Ella Shoaff daughter female, 17 born IN At home
Both parents born Ohio
Possible son, Samuel, of David M. Shoaff??
1880 Census of Cato, Montcalm, Michigan 55 B
Samuel Shoaf married male, 40 born Ohio Teamster
Both parents born Ohio
Lavercia Shoaf wife female, 34 born MI Keeps house
Father born Ireland, Mother born NY
Mary Shoaf daughter female, 16 born MI
Malissa Shoaf daughter female, 13 born IN
Ella Shoaf daughter female, 11 born IL
Irene Shoaf daughter female, 7 born IN
Peter Shoaf son male, 5 born IN
Edwin Shoaf son male, 1 born MI
Is this John “F” for Freeman Shoaff, son of John P. Shoaff, brother of David???
Mother would have been Pricilla Freeman.
1880 Census of Churubusco, Whitley Co., IN 383 B
John F. Shoaff married male, 48 born Ohio Broker
Father born PA, Mother born Ohio
Annie E. Shoaff wife female, 26 born IN Keeps house
Both parents born NJ
Pricilla Shoaff daughter female, 1 born IN
SHOAFF BURIALS AT PERRY TOWNSHIP CEMETERY, HUNTERTOWN IN
OLD SECTION:
SHOAFF, DAVID M. Dec. 16, 1814-June 13, 1890 Mary
SHOAFF, MARY Oct. 9, 1819-Oct. 1, 1888 David
SHOAFF, SARAH Feb. 26, 1867 23Y 10M 5D
Wife of Peter (next to and matching A. Allen)
ALLEN, ALMIRA Dec. 17, 1863 41Y (21) 11M 7D
Wife of John
ALLEN, ALMIRA Jan. 7, 1882 19Y 24D dau. J. & A.
The Shoaff family appears to have come from Miami County, Ohio. David M. Shoaff married his wife, Mary “Polly” Mendenhall there on March 13, 1836. She was the daughter of Joseph Mendenhall and Deidama Hill.
The 1835 Quadrennial Enumeration of Adult White Males of Miami County, Ohio, show the following of the Shoaff names there:
James B. Shoaff Monroe Township
John P. Shoaff Monroe Township
Thomas J. Shoaff Monroe Township
No ages listed but assume they were “of age” and probably over 21 at the time. Though David was married the next year, he would have been too young to be listed in 1835.
DESCENDANTS OF PETER SHOAFF
1. Peter Shoaff b: abt 1786 d: 1840 in Miami Co., Ohio
+ Sarah Elizabeth Musselman b: abt 1790 in PA
2. John P. Shoaff b: Oct. 13, 1804 in MD d: Feb. 1, 1887 in Whitley Co., IN
married Feb. 5, 1829 in Miami Co., Ohio
+ Priscilla Freeman b: Jan. 4, 1810 in Greene Co., Ohio d: May 22,
1880 in Allen Co., IN on home site (or May 1, 1881 from bio)
3. William W. Shoaff b: Nov. 15, 1829 in Miami Co., Ohio
d: May 17, 1907 in Ft. Wayne, married March 10, 1859
+ Eliza J. Work b: Jan. 18, 1839 in DeKalb Co., IN
4. John Robert Shoaff b: abt 1860 in Butler
Twp., DeKalb Co., IN
4. Joseph Y. Shoaff b: abt 1868 in Eel River
Twp., Allen Co., IN
+ Clara B. Glazier b: Sept. 22, 1867
in IN d: Feb. 18, 1950 in LA, CA
5. Robert Shoaff b: Dec 1891
5. Kate S. Shoaff b: April 26,
1900 d: Jan 25, 1990 in
Alhambra, LA Co., CA
+ Lester W. Kimball
b: March 14, 1892
in MA d: June
1969 in San Marino
3. John F. Shoaff b: Sept. 15, 1831 in Miami Co., Ohio
d: Sept 14, 1900 in Whitley Co., IN married Nov. 1857
+ Martha Elizabeth Work b: abt 1838 in DeKalb Co
d: March 18, 1868 or 1869
2nd wife of John F. Shoaff, married Sept. 11, 1872
+ Annie E. Johnson b: April 1855 in IN
4. Priscilla J. Shoaff b: abt 1878 d: May 1,
1883 in Whitley Co., IN
4. Eliza J. Shoaff b: June 28, 1881
d: Sept. 18, 1952 in San Diego Co., CA
married June 18, 1802 in Whitley Co., IN
+ John Charles Barth b: abt 1879 PA
5. James Barth
3. Henrietta Shoaff b: abt 1834 in Miami Co., Ohio
married Oct. 10, 1852 in Allen Co., IN
+ Marcus W. Bayless b: abt 1830 in Ohio
3. Louisa Shoaff b: abt 1838
3. James B. Shoaff b: Sept. 9, 1840 in Eel River Twp., Allen
Co., IN d: after 1920 married Sept. 22, 1864
+ Hulda H. DeVeny b: abt 1846 in Ohio
4. Oran L. Shoaff b: abt 1866 in IN
married Feb. 18, 1888 in Allen Co., IN
+ Clara Steinbert
4. Jerry or Terry Shoaff b: abt 1868
4. Jenney Shoaff b: about 1869
4. Frederick Barnett Shoaff b: Oct. 7, 1877
married June 21, 1904 in Vigo Co., IN
+ Alice Judith Dryer b: May 1879, IN
5. Thomas Richard Shoaff
b. March 9, 1909
d: May 13, 2005
m: 1942 Wash. D. C.
+ Phyllis M. Kleiner
6. Judith
6. Susan
6. Clare
6. Richard
6. Wally
5. Frederick D. Shoaff
b: Oct. 20, 1906
5. John D. Shoaff
b: Jan. 19, 1908
d: Oct. 1982 in Ft. Wayne
3. Matilda Jennie Shoaff b: Dec. 1843 in Allen Co., IN
married Feb. 1862
+ Alexander H. Bayless b: April 1837 in IN
4. Wilson W. Bayless b: abt 1863 in Allen Co.
4. Lillian Bayless b: abt 1871 in Allen Co., IN
4. George Willis Bayless b: Oct. 13, 1872
+ Anna A. Sweet
5. Maurice W. Bayless
b: Dec. 3, 1903
d: Nov. 1956 in MO
5. Arthur H. Bayless b: 1906
5. Lillian S. Bayless b: 1910
5. Katherine L. Bayless
b: abt 1916
4. Amelia H. Bayless b: April 1880
3. Allen P. Shoaff b: abt 1846, married Nov. 26, 1867
+ Elizabeth C. Shoaff (?) (dau. of Wade C. & Eliz??)
4. Annie M. Shoaff b: abt 1870
2nd wife of Allen P. Shoaff, married March 27, 1876
+ Alice M. Wamsley b: 1859 in Ohio
4. Arie M. Shoaff b: abt 1878
4. Indiana P. Shoaff b: Feb. 1880
married Aug. 19, 1897, Shelby Co., Ohio
+ William S. Delery
3. Wade Scott Shoaff b: Dec. 16, 1847 in Allen Co., IN
married March 11, 1885 in Allen Co., IN
+ Lena May Zimmerson b: Aug. 10, 1868
3. David Shoaff b: abt 1848
3. Annie E. Shoaff (may or may not be a daughter. Was
based on a newspaper article in which she was called
“daughter”. Might she have been daughter-in-law?)
2. James B. Shoaff b: abt 1807 in Ohio
married Feb. 2, 1851 in Miami Co., Ohio
+ Mary A. Daley
3. Alice M. Shoaff b: 1853 in Allen Co., IN m: May 10, 1870
+ James Sion Smith b: Aug. 3, 1849 in Livingston
Co., KY
4. Claude S. Smith b: abt 1879
4. Maude Muriel Smith b: Nov. 1881, Allen
3. James B. Shoaff b. abt 1857
3. Francis Shoaff b: abt 1859
2. Fianna Shoaff b: Dec. 30, 1811 in Hamilton, Ohio d: April 15, 1904 in
Huntertown, Allen Co., IN, married Dec. 11, 1833 in Montg. Co., Ohio
+ John Mendenhall b: Oct. 20, 1807 in Lost Creek, TN (Jeff. Co.)
d: Sept. 8, 1869 in Long Lake, IN

FIANNA SHOAFF MENDENHALL
FIND MORE ON THE MENDENHALL FAMILY UNDER THE NAME “MENDENHALL”
3. Elizabeth Mendenhall b: Sept. 17, 1835 in Dayton, Ohio
d: April 3, 1869 in Swan Twp., Noble Co., IN
+ Cornelius Loranzo Grimm b: Jan. 7, 1828 in
Baltimore, MD
4. Edward Frank Grimm b: 1857 Swan Twp.,
Noble Co., IN m: Feb. 29, 1888 in Kansas
+ Ella Amelia Burt b: abt 1868 in IL
4. Miranda Grimm b: 1861 in Ohio (?)
4. John Grimm b: Dec. 11, 1864 in Noble Co.
married July 9, 1890 Kingman Co., KS
+ Mollie C. Evans
4. Icie Mae Grimm b: abt 1868 d: bef 1880
4. Perry Lorenzo Grimm b: March 27, 1869 in
Swan Twp., Noble Co., IN
Married Aug. 3, 1889 in Allen Co., IN
+ Maud A. Mooney
5. Jess H. Grimm b: March
20, 1907 d: May1981 in
Ft. Wayne, IN
3. Isaac Mendenhall b: Nov. 5, 1837 in Dayton, Ohio
d: Dec. 1903 in Fort Wayne, Allen Co., IN
married Oct 6, 1863 in Noble Co., IN
+ Farla Ames Carver b: Dec. 1833 in Ohio
d: 1914 in Allen Co., IN
4. Fianna Ellsworth Mendenhall b: Oct 14,
1864 in Noble Co., IN d: Oct 1902 in
Fort Wayne, Allen Co., IN
Married April 30, 1889 in Allen Co., IN
+ Frederick A. Hull
4. Charlotte Lottie Mendenhall b: May 1868
married Jan 19, 1891 Allen Co., IN
+ Frank E. Bacome b: June 1864 Ohio
5. Harold Ellsworth Bacome
b: March 17, 1892
&nb